Agenda - July 2010 County Council Meeting

Back to Meetings
Date:
12/07/2010 15:30
Location:
Council Chamber
Standing Orders:

Headed Items

H-I (1)
Submitted by:
Corporate Performance and Change Management Directorate
Responsibility:
Mairead Hunt, Corporate Performance and Change Management Directorate

CONFIRMATION  AND  RE-AFFIRMATION  OF  MINUTES

a) Minutes of Meeting of South Dublin County Council, 14th June 2010

b) Minutes of Annual Meeting of South Dublin County Council, 25th June 2010

c) Minutes of Development Plan Meeting, 4th May 2010

d) Minutes of Development Plan Meeting, 6th May 2010

e) Minutes of Development Plan Meeting, 10th May 2010

f) Minutes of Development Plan Meeting, 11th May 2010

g) Minutes of Development Plan Meeting, 13th May 2010

H-I (2)
Submitted by:
Corporate Performance and Change Management Directorate
Responsibility:
Roads Department, Housing Administration, Planning Not is use

REPORTS  OF  AREA  COMMITTEES                        

a) Rathfarnham Area Committee - 8th June 2010

Dealing with Roads, Planning, Development & Parks, Corporate & Library Services, Community, Environment, Housing

(no reports)

 b) Lucan Clondalkin Area Committee (1) - 16th June 2010

Dealing with Planning, Development & Parks, Roads (1 report - Initiate a comprehensive analysis of traffic congestion on the road network in Lucan south of N4)

(to be circulated)

 c) Lucan Clondalkin Area Committee (2) - 22nd June 2010

Dealing with Housing, Environment, Community (1 report - Community Grants), Corporate & Library Services

(circulated herewith)

 d) Tallaght Area Committee (1) - 21st June 2010

Dealing with Environment, Community (1 report - Community Grants), Housing 

(circulated herewith)

 e) Tallaght Area Committee (2) - 28th June 2010

Dealing with Roads, Planning, Development & Parks, Corporate & Library Services

 (no reports)

H-I (3)
Submitted by:
Corporate Performance and Change Management Directorate
Responsibility:
Corporate Performance and Change Management Directorate

STANDING COMMITTEES  -  ORGANISATION,  PROCEDURE  AND FINANCE COMMITTEE

(no report)

H-I (4)
Submitted by:
Corporate Performance and Change Management Directorate
Responsibility:
Philomena Poole

STRATEGIC  POLICY  COMMITTEES

Environment Strategic Policy Committee

(i) Report of Meeting held 17th May 2010

(ii) Minutes of Meeting 25th January 2010

(all circulated herewith)

H-I (5)
Submitted by:
Corporate Performance and Change Management Directorate
Responsibility:

REPORTS  REQUESTED  BY  AREA  COMMITTEES

(no reports)

Questions

Qu (1)
Submitted by:
Councillor E. Coburn
Responsibility:
Sheila Kelly, Rachel Jackson

To ask the Manager why the Boherboy Water Supply Scheme which went for tender in June 2006 was not a fixed price contract and to outline in detail the statutory provision in relation to the Government announcement on 20 May 2006 with regard to the public sector construction procurement reforms, The Capital Works Management Framework?  (Original announcement May 2004 as per answer to Q2 May 2010 Council meeting)

Qu (2)
Submitted by:
Councillor E. Coburn
Responsibility:
Sheila Kelly, Rachel Jackson

To ask the Manager to detail the Boherboy Water Supply Scheme costs associated with each of the variations as detailed below:  reinstatement, telemetry, actuated valves and chlorine dosing and Claims (such as restricted access to lands), on the project to date?

Qu (3)
Submitted by:
Councillor E. Coburn
Responsibility:
Sheila Kelly, Rachel Jackson

To ask the Manager to outline the expected completion date of the Boherboy Water Supply Scheme?

Qu (4)
Submitted by:
Councillor E. Coburn
Responsibility:
Michael Hannon

To ask the Manager to report on the number of council staff engaged in grass-cutting over the summer months this year compared with each of 2008 & 2009, the number of external contractors engaged in grass-cutting over the summer months this year compared with each of 2008 & 2009 and the costs incurred in each year to retain these services?

Qu (5)
Submitted by:
Councillor E. Coburn
Responsibility:
Teresa Walsh, Philomena Poole

To ask the Manager to report on any agreement between the council and staff unions with regard to the engaging of external contractors and community employment schemes to carry out environmental works such as grass cutting ?

Qu (6)
Submitted by:
Councillor E. Coburn
Responsibility:
Martin Judge, John McLoughlin, John Browne, Patricia Doherty

To ask the Manager to detail the construction projects currently in progess with the council and planned with the council that are fixed contract and "non-fixed contract"?

Qu (7)
Submitted by:
Councillor R. Dowds
Responsibility:
Michael Hannon

To ask the Manager to outline the grass cutting schedule for South Dublin at present?

Qu (8)
Submitted by:
Councillor R. Dowds
Responsibility:
Colm Ward

To ask the Manager to outline the litter collection schedule from public bins in our County?

Qu (9)
Submitted by:
Councillor R. Dowds
Responsibility:
Michael Hannon

To ask the Manager to what extent he regards the cutting of grass in public places to be a priority and to what extent he feels that the grass cutting schedule is adequate?

Qu (10)
Submitted by:
Councillor J. Hannon
Responsibility:
Colm Ward

To ask the Manager to provide details of the 'priority areas' where litter bins have been erected in 2010, to date, and where it is planned to provide same during the remainder of this year?

Qu (11)
Submitted by:
Councillor J. Hannon
Responsibility:
Colm Ward

To ask the Manager to provide details of all areas, if any, in which litter bins have been erected, or are proposed to be erected, during 2010?

Qu (12)
Submitted by:
Councillor J. Hannon
Responsibility:
Colm Ward

To ask the Manager to confirm that it is Council policy (and practice) to provide litter bins at all bus stops?

Qu (13)
Submitted by:
Councillor J. Hannon
Responsibility:
Martin Judge

To ask the Manager to confirm the number of planning applications and retentions for mobile telephone masts received by SDCC during the past 5 years and the number granted and refused, together with the number subsequently appealed to An Bord Pleanala and the outcome?

Qu (14)
Submitted by:
Councillor W. Lavelle
Responsibility:
Martin Judge

To ask the Manager to report on the number of residential units for which commencement notices were lodged with the Building Control Authority in each of 2006, 2007, 2008 & 2009 and in the first six months of 2010?

Qu (15)
Submitted by:
Councillor W. Lavelle
Responsibility:
Sheila Kelly

To ask the Manager to provide a detailed update on the preparation Flood Risk Assessment and Management Studies for river catchment areas in the county?

Qu (16)
Submitted by:
Councillor W. Lavelle
Responsibility:
John McLoughlin, Sean O'Byrne

To ask the Manager to report on discussions with the National Roads Authority regarding our request for supplementary funding for the purposes of implementing grass cutting along the verges and medians of national primary roads including the required stringent health & safety arrangements; and further to question no. 7 at the July 2009 council meeting (some 12 months ago) to provide a further update on efforts to secure the necessary training and approved health and safety accreditation for council staff so that they can carry-out both the grass-cutting and the required health & safety arrangements?

Qu (17)
Submitted by:
Councillor W. Lavelle
Responsibility:
Willie Sheils

To ask the Manager to report on efforts to support the establishment of new youth cafes around the county including any proposals received or approved by the County Development Board under the POBAL youth café funding scheme?

Qu (18)
Submitted by:
Councillor W. Lavelle
Responsibility:
Mary Maguire

To ask the Manager to write to the Minister of State for Mental Health to request details of recent or proposed investment in mental health services in or serving South Dublin County including details of the reinvestment of monies raised from the sale of former psychiatric facilities in South Dublin County?

Qu (19)
Submitted by:
Councillor W. Lavelle
Responsibility:
Willie Sheils

To ask the Manager to provide an update on efforts to deliver new swimming pools across the county including an update on any proposals from and/or discussions with private parties relating to possible joint venture initiatives?

Qu (20)
Submitted by:
Councillor G. O'Connell
Responsibility:
John Browne

To ask the Manager for a detailed account of the actual annual cost to the Council in respect of the provision and maintenance of Allotments by location and the total income generated for the Council through the rent of the Allotments?

Qu (21)
Submitted by:
Councillor E. Tuffy
Responsibility:
Teresa Walsh, Philomena Poole, Mary Maguire

To ask the Manager if the Minister for Environment, Heritage and Local Government, or his officials has had any formal discussions with him as Manager, or any Council officials, about anticipated changes in the functions and powers of South Dublin County Council, including its reserved functions, which will come into effect if and when a directly elected Dublin Region Mayor takes office? 

Qu (22)
Submitted by:
Councillor E. Tuffy
Responsibility:
Larry Kelly

To ask the Manager for an updated report on income received in respect of commercial rate payments since 1st January 2010, to provide a figure for the estimated total income anticipated in the whole of 2010, and if he will make a statement on the matter?

Qu (23)
Submitted by:
Councillor E. Tuffy
Responsibility:
Colm Ward

To ask the Manager for an updated report on the income received from the black bin household waste collection since 1st January, how the income received compares with the anticipated income and if he will make a statement on the matter?

Qu (24)
Submitted by:
Councillor E. Tuffy
Responsibility:
Sheila Kelly, Rachel Jackson

To ask the Manager if he will make a report on the current situation in respect of the Council's security of water supply, if any shortages are being experienced in any areas, and the anticipated outlook for the remainder of the year?

Qu (25)
Submitted by:
Councillor E. Tuffy
Responsibility:
Sheila Kelly, Rachel Jackson

To ask the Manager if he will provide a report on current works being undertaken to improve and maintain the Council's water supply infrastructure, how much it is anticipated will be spent on such works in 2010 and how much was spent in 2009?

Qu (26)
Submitted by:
Councillor E. Tuffy
Responsibility:
Martin Judge

Noting the reply to Question 25 at the June 2010 meeting of the Council, which reveals that approximately €34 million in Development Levy Contributions invoiced to developers by the Council remain unpaid , to ask the Manager if it will be possible to have some of the outstanding monies recovered from developers through NAMA,  to ask further if County Managers have raised this issue of payments of unpaid development levies with NAMA or the Minister for Finance, and further to ask if the Council can make public the names of development companies which individually  owe substantial amounts, say in excess of €1 million, in unpaid levies to South Dublin County Council?

Headed Items

H-I (6)
Submitted by:
Corporate Performance and Change Management Directorate
Responsibility:
Roads Department

DECLARATION  OF  ROADS  TO  BE  PUBLIC  ROADS

a) Cooldrinagh Lane

b) Abbeywood Court

(all circulated herewith)

H-I (7)
Submitted by:
Corporate Performance and Change Management Directorate
Responsibility:
Housing Administration, Development, Econ. & Transport Planning Dept.

PROPOSED  DISPOSAL  OF  PROPERTIES / SITES

(all circulated herewith)

b) Lease of Telecommunication Duct in Grange Castle Business Park to BT Communications Ireland Limited.


c) Proposed land exchange at Monastery Gate, Red Cow/M50 Roundabout, Clondalkin, Dublin 22 – South Dublin County Council and Cherrybridge Properties Limited


a) Proposed Disposal of Affordable Dwellings

(no report)

H-I (8)
Submitted by:
Community Services
Responsibility:
Willie Sheils

REPORT ON PART 8 - FLOODLIGHTING SCHEME AT THE FETTERCAIRN HORSE PROJECT

(circulated herewith)

H-I (9)
Submitted by:
Thomas Curtin
Responsibility:
Thomas Curtin

REPORT ON PROPOSED EXTINGUISHMENT OF PUBLIC RIGHT OF WAY OVER OLD COOLDRINAGH LANE, LUCAN

(circulated herewith)

H-I (10)
Submitted by:
Philip Murphy
Responsibility:
Philip Murphy
H-I (11)
Submitted by:
Mary Kelly - Finance
Responsibility:
Patricia McLoughlin, Mary Kelly - Finance

a)  UNAUDITED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENT 2009

b)  AUTHORISATION OF OVER EXPENDITURE 2009

(all circulated herewith)

H-I (12)
Submitted by:
Philomena Poole
Responsibility:
Philomena Poole

REVIEW OF DOMESTIC WASTE CHARGES

(circulated herewith)

H-I (13)
Submitted by:
Maire Ni Dhomhnaill
Responsibility:
Corporate Performance and Change Management Directorate

DRAFT ANNUAL REPORT 2009

(circulated herewith)

H-I (14)
Submitted by:
Corporate Performance and Change Management Directorate
Responsibility:
Mary Maguire

FILLING OF VACANCY (CHAIR) ON HOUSING & SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT SPC FOLLOWING RESIGNATION OF COUNCILLOR E. MALONEY

(circulated herewith)

Correspondence

Cor (1)
Submitted by:
Corporate Performance and Change Management Directorate
Responsibility:
Corporate Performance and Change Management Directorate

Ministerial

Correspondence, dated 25th June, from Minister for Enterprise, Trade & Employment in relation to motion passed regarding work placement scheme.

Cor (2)
Submitted by:
Corporate Performance and Change Management Directorate
Responsibility:
Corporate Performance and Change Management Directorate

Correspondence, dated 31st May 2010, from Roscommon County Council to Minister for Environment in relation to their motion regarding Childcare costs.

Cor (3)
Submitted by:
Mary Maguire
Responsibility:
Corporate Performance and Change Management Directorate

Correspondence, dated 3rd June 2010, from Dublin City University in relation to SDCC's letter regarding nomination to Governing Authority of Dublin City University.

Cor (4)
Submitted by:
Corporate Performance and Change Management Directorate
Responsibility:
Corporate Performance and Change Management Directorate

Correspondence, dated 4th June 2010, from Limerick Co Council in relation to their motion passed regarding Commercial Rates.

Cor (5)
Submitted by:
Corporate Performance and Change Management Directorate
Responsibility:
Corporate Performance and Change Management Directorate

Correspondence, dated 23rd June 2010, from Donegal County Council in relation to their motion passed regarding Vehicle Registration Tax.

Cor (6)
Submitted by:
Corporate Performance and Change Management Directorate
Responsibility:
Corporate Performance and Change Management Directorate

Correspondence, dated 24th June 2010, from National Transport Authority in response to Council's letter regarding the Greater Dublin Area road network.

Motions

Mot (1)
Submitted by:
Councillor E. Maloney
Responsibility:
Jim Walsh (Development Business), Emer O'Gorman

MAYORS BUSINESS

That this Council in an effort to promote the County as a prime location for new industry supports the re-establishment of a local I.D.A. office.

To this end, we request that the Minister for Enterprise, Trade and Innovation, Mr Batt O’ Keeffe would meet with the Mayor, County Manager and representatives of South Dublin Chamber

Mot (2)
Submitted by:
Councillor D. Keating
Responsibility:
Colm Ward, Sorcha O'Brien

That the Manager would present a detailed report for discussion on how this Council supports schools in the County, including schools that make a particular effort on environmental matters such as reducing, reusing and recycling.  Would the Manager also report on how the Council can continue to support and encourage schools, including children, students, teachers and parents who participate in such school projects and lead by great example.

Mot (3)
Submitted by:
Councillor C. King
Responsibility:
Corporate Performance and Change Management Directorate

That this Council calls on the Minister for Health to reverse the decision to ban medical card holders from dental procedures other than emergency work as this will have a serious negative impact on the oral health of a significant proportion of the population particularly pensioners and is a serious threat to employees jobs in the dental profession.

Mot (4)
Submitted by:
Councillor W. Lavelle
Responsibility:
Mary Maguire

That this Council requests the Manager to present a detailed report for discussion on efforts to introduce appropriate work-placement/training programmes to gainfully engage unemployed persons in projects such as environmental improvement works as requested by this council in a motion adopted at the March council meeting.

Mot (5)
Submitted by:
Councillor G. Kenny
Responsibility:
Corporate Performance and Change Management Directorate

This Council condemns the government for the drastic consequences which the cuts in local authority funding are having on the provision of services at council level. These cuts will impact most on the most disadvantaged areas and on the most vulnerable within them. 
This government is responsible for the greatest economic and financial crises in the history of the state. The current economic crisis is the result of years of neo-liberal economic policies that have favoured the interests of big business and profit over the needs of people and the environment. The greed and corruption of the ruling elite now threaten our country with catastrophe and this Council records a vote of no confidence in the Fianna Fail/Green Party government.

Mot (6)
Submitted by:
Councillor R. Dowds
Responsibility:
Mary Kelly - Corporate Services, Aine O'Brien

That this Council asks that Councillors are informed about land purchases by South Dublin County Council every time such a land purchase is completed.

Mot (7)
Submitted by:
Councillor J. Lahart
Responsibility:
Martin Judge, Colm Ward

That the Manager outline what laws/bye-laws govern, and what licenses are required for, vendors who set up outside churches to sell newspapers on Sundays, and that the manager agrees that these are proving inadequate and are in need of review in order to regulate and licence such practices more appropriately and to open the matter up to public consultation

Mot (8)
Submitted by:
Councillor B. Lawlor
Responsibility:
Colm Ward

That this Council while acknowledging the hard work of the Parks and Environment maintenance staff calls on the Manager to once and for all address the ongoing problem of when residents associations or voluntary groups agree a pick up date for rubbish and green waste after an estate or park cleanup by them that this council collects within a set time frame 1-3 days of agreed date.

Mot (9)
Submitted by:
Councillor W. Lavelle
Responsibility:
John Quinlivan

That this Council requests the Manager to present a detailed report to form the basis for discussion with the elected member on proposals to improve the management of the public realm in our county, including the need for improved and more regular litter-cleansing and grass-cutting services and the need to pursue greater coordination and innovative working arrangements between council departments and noting the provision of funding in the adopted budget for 2010 for ‘public realm transformation’. 

Mot (10)
Submitted by:
Councillor D. Looney
Responsibility:
Mary Maguire

That this Council, in light of the ongoing suffering of the Palestinian people, recognises (1) that Veolia is a leading partner in the consortium contracted to build a light railway system linking Israel to illegal settlements in occupied East Jerusalem, (2) that the Irish government and the U.N does not recognise Israel’s annexation and occupation of East Jerusalem and have repeatedly stated their views that the Israeli settlements in East Jerusalem and the West Bank contravene international law and (3) that Veolia’s involvement in the project is in contravention of the UN’s stated demand that Israeli settlement activities and occupation should not be supported, and calls on the County Manager not to sign any new or renew any existing contracts with Veolia.

Mot (11)
Submitted by:
Councillor C. King
Responsibility:
Corporate Performance and Change Management Directorate

That this Council Condemns the Israeli attack on the Gaza Freedom Flotilla’s aid mission that resulted in deaths and injuries of those attempting to bring much needed aid to the besieged city of Gaza, which has been subject to an illegal Israeli blockade.

Commends those Irish citizens who participated in this humanitarian mission to bring 10,000 tones of aid to the people of Gaza.

Recognizing that this attack is an affront to international law and has endangered the lives of Irish citizens, calls on the Irish Government to expel the Israeli  Ambassador, use it’s influence to discontinue the EU’s preferential trade agreement with Israel and Support and seek the backing of other countries for a new international aid mission to Gaza which will ensure that necessary vital supplies reach the suffering people of that besieged area.

Mot (12)
Submitted by:
Councillor J. Lahart
Responsibility:
Avril Mullins

That the Manager outline the legal costs of the Council in 2008 and 2009 in total and by department as requested by me at a pre-budget meeting.

Mot (13)
Submitted by:
Councillor E. Walsh 2009
Responsibility:
Colm Ward

That this Council calls for the reintroduction of the annual/biennial junk collection in order to reduce the level of fly-tipping in the county.

Mot (14)
Submitted by:
Councillor T. Ridge
Responsibility:
Paul Fleming

That this Council asks the Minister of State for housing to meet a delegation of local Cllrs. and housing staff to request him to review the Housing (miscellaneous) Act 1997 to allow for realistic and effective methods of dealing with the escalating anti-social problem in local authority housing.  The review to include effective measures to prohibit tenants engaging in said activities and to include measures to deal with same problem in privately owned houses in Council estates.

Mot (15)
Submitted by:
Councillor R. Dowds
Responsibility:
Yvonne Dervan

That South Dublin County Council enacts the Parks Bye-Laws so that the Gardai can enforce them.