Search
To ask the Chief Executive to set out, in tabular form by electoral area, the number of planning enforcement cases being investigated, setting out when each case commenced and the estimated completion date in respect of each.
8. Motion in the names of Cllr Liona O'Toole, Guss O'Connell, Paul Gogarty CE response to submission SD-C195-120 Pg 809 Motion seeks to add in additional wording 'into accounts areas without any such infrastructure, and' Amend from: To prepare a feasibility study for the development of Arts and Culture Infrastructure within the County, taking account of transport links To: To prepare a feasibility study for the development of Arts and Culture Infrastructure within the County, taking into account areas without any such infrastructure, and taking account of transport links
SD-C-227 OPR Page 59 Public Rights of Way that the review of public rights of way would include other points of access to the SAAO Liffey Valley riverbank such as that adjacent to the Scouts Den between Chapel Hill and the River Bank, the entrance from the Old Rectory to the river bank and that there be an audit of all publicly owned lands near the river bank be they owned by any public authority including OPW, HSE etc.
To ask the Chief Executive to set out particulars of matters covered by the Community Activities Fund and how it may be applied for
Chapter 8 SD-C195-55 St. Patrick's Mental Health Services Page 782 of the CE Report re St. Patrick's Hospital submission
To amend the CE Recommendation from:
NCBH7 SLO2: To work in collaboration with the owners of St Patricks Hospital lands at St Edmundsbury, Lucan in the preparation of a Masterplan to examine the potential for the future provision of mental health services and accommodation on the existing hospital campus lands. The Masterplan will have full regard to the setting and integrity of the Protected Structures on the lands, the highly sensitive environmental characteristics of the site in relation to the Liffey Valley and Green Infrastructure principles and the need to provide appropriate public access to the lands
To:
To work in collaboration with the owners of St Patricks Hospital lands at St Edmundsbury, Lucan in the preparation of a Masterplan to examine the potential for the future provision of mental health services and accommodation on the existing hospital campus lands. The Masterplan will have full regard to the setting and integrity of the Protected Structures on the lands, the highly sensitive environmental characteristics of the site in relation to the Liffey Valley and Green Infrastructure principles and the need to provide appropriate public access including an area of accessible public realm within the lands and connectivity to adjacent lands to further the overall objective of developing a Liffey Valley public park
To ask the Chief Executive what measures are in place to protect and ensure public safety in our public parks and open spaces in terms of security measures and otherwise
7. Motion in the names of Cllr Liona O'Toole, Guss O'Connell, Paul Gogarty SD-C195-254 (Garda station Clonburris) page 739 This submission has a request for an SLO to be inserted into the plan and motion asks that this committee supports the submission as follows: 'insert a Special Local Objective for the provision of a Garda Station in Clonburris'
This motion relates to Chapter 10 Energy, submission SD-C195-181 on page 877 of the CE report. To remove the following sentence from the new Section 11.5 Electricity Infrastructure: It is recognised that natural gas, particularly renewable and indigenous gas, will have a role to play in the transition to a low carbon economy. As such, renewable energy developments may require support from such sources in times of high energy demand. Reason: Neither natural gas nor so called renewable natural gas should be regarded as a greener alternative to other fossil fuels. Natural gas is a fossil fuel and should be phased out as soon as possible. It's still debatable whether or not RNG is a good alternative with many climate scientists advising against the replacing of natural gas with RNG.
This motion relates to chapter 6 Housing, submission SD-C195-229 on page 523 of the CE report. To remove the following sentence from the CE recommendation to Amend H1 Objective 13: (excluding Build-to-Rent developments) The amended Objective to read: Proposals for residential shall provide a minimum of 30% 3-bedroom units, a lesser provision may be acceptable where it can be demonstrated that: ? there are unique site constraints that would prevent such provision or ? that the proposed housing mix meets the specific demand required in an area, having regard to the prevailing housing type within a 10-minute walk of the site and to the socioeconomic, population and housing data set out in the Housing Strategy and Interim HNDA; or ? the scheme is a social and/or affordable housing scheme Reason: With the large number of Build-To-Rent developments this amendment would effectively render the Objective useless and would even encourage more unaffordable Build-to-Rent developments.
This motion relates to chapter 9 Economic Development & Employment, submission SD-C195-119 on page 829 of the CE report. To reject the CE recommendation of No change and ban data centres by moving Data Centre to Not Permitted under all zoning. Reason: It has become even more clear since the last Development Plan discussions that there is no more capacity for further data centres in the South Dublin area. EirGrid announced in December that it would not grant any further connections in the Dublin area until 2028. Since this coincides with dates of this plan it would be prudent to ban all new data centres for the duration of the plan.
This motion relates to chapter 2 Core Strategy and Settlement Strategy, submission SD-C195-205 on page 155 of the CE report. To reject the new Objective CS 1 Objective 4: To engage with the Land Development Agency (LDA) in the planning and co-ordination of strategic land banks to achieve compact growth, sustainable development and urban regeneration. Reason: A discussion was held in 2021 regarding the LDA where councillors unanimously agreed that we wished for SDCC to develop its own lands, so this objective is not necessary or wanted.
This motion relates to chapter 2.3 Observations, submission and recommendations from the NTA, submission SD-C195--245 on page 93 of the CE Report. To retain the 'Kennelsfort Rd and the R148' and associated text in Table 7.5 under the Six Year Road Programme.
6. Motion in the names of Cllr Liona O'Toole, Guss O'Connell, Paul Gogarty SD-C195-2 CSD-C195-2E response page 609 Motion seeks to remove ADAMSTOWN, CLONBURRIS and create a separate policy for Adamstown and Clonburris Amend from: SM3 Objective 12: To work with the NTA to secure the expansion of the bus network to serve new development and regeneration areas within the South Dublin County area including Tallaght, Naas Road, Adamstown, Clonburris, Fortunestown, Ballycullen and Newcastle. To: SM3 Objective 12: To work with the NTA to secure the expansion of the bus network to serve new development and regeneration areas within the South Dublin County area including Tallaght, Naas Road, Fortunestown, Ballycullen and Newcastle. New SM3 Objective? To work with the NTA to ensure the delivery of distinct new bus networks in Clonburris and Adamstown SDZ developments.
Chapter 8 CE Report p.736; SD-C195-11 That SDCC attaches a SLO to the playing pitches at St. Colmcilles Way occupied currently by Knocklyon United for provision of Astro playing facilities at the site
Chapter 8 CE Report p.736; SD-C195-11 That SDCC makes provision for a SLO for a swimming pool complex serving the growing Ballycullen, Knocklyon and Firhouse communities in this Development Plan
Chapter 2 Core Strategy CE Report pages: 308-312 Submission SD-C195-257 To rezone the lands on attached map marked in red from OS and RU to EE and to include a SLO as follows: 'To facilitate warehousing and ancillary uses at the former Hazel Grove Golf Club, Kiltalown, Saggart, off the N81 National Secondary Road subject to proper planning and sustainable development including protection of the operating capacity and safety of the N81 and its junction with Mount Seskin Road.' REASON: National and regional policy is rightly to increase density in urban areas, such as Tallaght. This has a negative impact on necessary, if less valuable, lower order warehouse / distribution land uses, which may be forced to relocate to areas remote from the urban centres. In order to ensure a margin of flexibility in the Development Plan for the facilitation of such lower order warehouse/distribution related uses, including the need to retain such necessary uses within the County, but which are planned to be displaced by higher density residential and mixed use developments from more centrally located lands in the Tallaght area (e.g. Cookstown) and noting the impediments to agricultural use of portion of the lands subject of the submission, it is proposed to rezone lands at Kiltalown, Saggart, as recommended by the CEO, from OS to RU with the addition that the northernmost section in the land holding (bounded to the south by the Irish Water main) be rezoned to EE with an SLO
Chapter 8 CE Report p.736; SD-C195-11 Insert a new objective ‘To provide for a public library to serve the growing Ballycullen, Knocklyon and Firhouse communities and indoor civic space to meet the inter-generational requirements of local communities including performance and exhibition space, indoor sports and artistic, cultural and recreational use’
REASON: To date, local communities have provided their own community facilities - which have long since exhausted the demands on them. Such space to include and cater for community needs, performance and exhibition space, indoor sports and artistic, cultural and recreational use
MOTION Section 2.3 , Submission Number SD C195 - 245, Page 92 and 93 of the CE Report, (Ref Policy SM3) To change the Chief Executive's Recommendation as follows: FROM: Amend Table 7.5 to remove reference to 'Kennelsfort Road and the R148' and associated text and insert the same into Table 7.6 Medium to Long Term Road Objectives. TO: The Council shall work with the NTA and other state agencies to facilitate the delivery of the Kennelsfort Road-R148 grade separated junction or an equivalent solution to be initiated during the first two years of the 2022-2028 Development Plan and adjust the relevant tables as appropriate to reflect this objective. EXPLAINATION: The intent of the motion is to restore the original objective as set out in the Draft Plan. The Council, and successive County Development Plans, going back to the 1990s has promoted the objective of a grade separated junction at Kennelsfort Road/N4 (now Kennelsfort Road/R148). Now is the time to begin to deliver on this objective especially given the National commitment to address Climate change and its causes. The NRA is not addressing the issue when it states '….that there will be no significant increase in road capacity for private vehicles on radial roads inside the M50 Motorway'. (Michael Mac Ardee, Head of Strategic Planning, NRA, 15th September 2021). Road capacity is not the issue here. The need for a separated junction at this location is required in the first instance to re-unite the divided community of Palmerstown, to promote connectivity. The Community was divided to facilitate the realignment of the Lucan Road in the 1980s by the creation of the then N4, more recently downgraded from a national to a regional road. But the traffic has increased, not lessened. Secondly it creates an unnecessary source of both air and noise pollution in the midst of a residential area, especially at peak times, as motor vehicles are halted in both directions by unnecessary traffic signals. The current arrangement does not support an efficient BusConnect system. Neither does it promote or foster cyclists or pedestrians. The time has come to deliver on this long held objective. Councillors Guss O'Connell, Liona O'Toole, Paul Gogarty,
CE Report Errata Document B Relating to issues raised in submissions on Whitechurch/Edmondstown Chapter 7 Sustainable Movement and to Edward Fox submission SD-C195-52
That a DMURS compliant link road with associated pedestrian and cycle paths be provided from the College Road /Whitechurch Road junction to the Edmonstown Road as a 6-year transportation objective, to address issues of accessibility across the Edmondstown Lands and the wider area to provides links to existing routes, services and recreational facilities in the area.
5. Motion in the names of Cllr Liona O'Toole, Guss O'Connell, Paul Gogarty SD-C195-2 CE Response pg.608 Chapter 7 Motion seeks to add in NEW AND EXISTING Amend from: SM3 Objective 6: To establish future public transport routes that will support the County's medium to long term development, including orbital routes to provide connectivity between outer suburban areas. To: SM3 Objective 6: To establish future public transport routes that will support the County's medium to long term development, including NEW AND EXISTING orbital routes to provide connectivity between outer suburban areas.